Browse ByCategories |
Q:
My close friend and hunting buddy has found the love of hunting mule deer and elk in Colorado. He can only afford to own one hunting rifle for both species and has a total budget of $800-$1100 (rifle and scope). He is leaning towards a .270 or 30.06, but has an open mind for other calibers. He does not like heavy recoil (who does) has he wants some range time between seasons. He is looking for suggestions for rifle and caliber. Most shots are between 150-300 yards.
I've suggested the following:
Browning XBolt .270 w/Leupold 3x9x40 VXII
Marlin XL7 25-06/.270/30.06 and spend more on optics
(but he prefers a detachable magazine)
Your input is highly appreciated, as what counts most is feedback from actual users.
from Bull Elk on 10.29.12 |
ADVERTISEMENT |
Visit Our Sister Sites at Bonnier Corporation
|
Outdoorlife.com is part of the Field & Stream Network, a division of Bonnier Corporation.
Copyright © 2013 Bonnier Corp. All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.
Print
Email
Share
Answers (8)
DSMbirddog
I'm doing well. Back from my Colorado hunt and already wish I was headed back. Taking my new bird dog "Timmy"...hey, my wife named him, out for his first pheasant hunt Monday. Will be sending the new Brittany puppy "Posey" to bird training in early January.
Winchester .300 mag with Luepold 3-9x40
25-06 I haven't seen you out here for a while. How have you been?
I would recommend the Weatherby Vanguard in .300 Weatherby magnum. It will drop an elk in its tracks, and the recoil to me is not much harder then a 30-06. Mine was under 800 dollars and that was with a good scope on it.
Savage makes one hell of a rifle, he needs to shoot what he can handle with the recoil. If its to much he won't shoot well. The scope thing, go with the best you can buy, you get what you pay for, take a cheap scope and a higher end one like a Leupold or Nikkon at dusk or on a foggy morning and you will see. It would suck to go on a hunt of a lifetime and the scope fog or not be clear at crunch time. JMO
I think he would be better off getting a higher end rifle (Browning X-Bolt, Winchester Model 70, Remington 700) chambered in 7mm Rem Mag or .30-06 and buying one of the lower priced Leupold scopes. For shots under 300 yards a really high end scope isn't necessary.
-Plus if your friend ever wishes to upgrade to a better scope in the future he would already have a great rifle he was familiar with.
A 270 or 30-06 would be fine. But I would also check out the 7mm Rem mag and the 300 Win mag. I have Savage Mod 116 with Accutrigger and Accustock that I set up with a Leupold VX-2 and Warne mounts and rings for less than $1100. Others to consider are the T/C bolt actions and the Weatherby Vanguards
I have two rifles that I might suggest. One is a Savage Model 11 in .300 WSM that I bought new as a package gun for less than 500.00. It has a Simmons 8pt 3-9X40 scope that I was going to upgrade, but it has done so well that I see no reason to switch it out at this point. Not the prettiest gun, but if I miss with it, it isn’t the rifle’s problem. I have shot a nice Colorado bull and several white tail deer with it. The other rifle I would suggest is a Remington model 700 BDL. (Has the detachable mag.) It is chambered in 7mm Mag. and I topped it with a Leupold Vari X III 3.5X10-50. I've shot whitetail deer with this rifle and with the right bullet weight; I wouldn’t hesitate to hunt elk with it. It is one of the most accurate rifles I own.
Post an Answer (200 characters or less)
I have two rifles that I might suggest. One is a Savage Model 11 in .300 WSM that I bought new as a package gun for less than 500.00. It has a Simmons 8pt 3-9X40 scope that I was going to upgrade, but it has done so well that I see no reason to switch it out at this point. Not the prettiest gun, but if I miss with it, it isn’t the rifle’s problem. I have shot a nice Colorado bull and several white tail deer with it. The other rifle I would suggest is a Remington model 700 BDL. (Has the detachable mag.) It is chambered in 7mm Mag. and I topped it with a Leupold Vari X III 3.5X10-50. I've shot whitetail deer with this rifle and with the right bullet weight; I wouldn’t hesitate to hunt elk with it. It is one of the most accurate rifles I own.
Savage makes one hell of a rifle, he needs to shoot what he can handle with the recoil. If its to much he won't shoot well. The scope thing, go with the best you can buy, you get what you pay for, take a cheap scope and a higher end one like a Leupold or Nikkon at dusk or on a foggy morning and you will see. It would suck to go on a hunt of a lifetime and the scope fog or not be clear at crunch time. JMO
A 270 or 30-06 would be fine. But I would also check out the 7mm Rem mag and the 300 Win mag. I have Savage Mod 116 with Accutrigger and Accustock that I set up with a Leupold VX-2 and Warne mounts and rings for less than $1100. Others to consider are the T/C bolt actions and the Weatherby Vanguards
I think he would be better off getting a higher end rifle (Browning X-Bolt, Winchester Model 70, Remington 700) chambered in 7mm Rem Mag or .30-06 and buying one of the lower priced Leupold scopes. For shots under 300 yards a really high end scope isn't necessary.
-Plus if your friend ever wishes to upgrade to a better scope in the future he would already have a great rifle he was familiar with.
I would recommend the Weatherby Vanguard in .300 Weatherby magnum. It will drop an elk in its tracks, and the recoil to me is not much harder then a 30-06. Mine was under 800 dollars and that was with a good scope on it.
25-06 I haven't seen you out here for a while. How have you been?
Winchester .300 mag with Luepold 3-9x40
DSMbirddog
I'm doing well. Back from my Colorado hunt and already wish I was headed back. Taking my new bird dog "Timmy"...hey, my wife named him, out for his first pheasant hunt Monday. Will be sending the new Brittany puppy "Posey" to bird training in early January.
Post an Answer (200 characters or less)