|
|
|
Welcome to Outdoor Life
Browse ByTop UsersTOP USERS |
Q:
I have friends who hunt out of the window of their vehicle. in my opinion its not hunting, youre just out shooting. i think you should hunt the right way on foot. what do you think
from tanner.leibel on 10.21.09 Answer Question |
ADVERTISEMENT |
Answers (25)
That's not hunting, that's illegal; illegal in my home state anyway...What about the rest of you? Is it illegal in your home state to hunt like tanner.leibel mentions? People like that give hunters a bad name and I would not label them hunters, but poachers. I wouldn't put it past those 'hunters' to go out at night with a spot light, a few beers, and continue their shooting out of a vehicle routine. Stick with your way of hunting tanner.leibel, you are doing it right.
I don't like it at all, even where it might be legal. In most places, that's poaching.
If they are parked on their own property, its not poaching. However I don't like it. My father in law likes to ride around on our places and hunt. He doesnt like to sit in a stand. I dont know if this is what the op was talking about but either way its not hunting.
Illegal in Mt.
Definitely not hunting. If my friends did that they would very quickly become my ex-friends.
In my more paranoid moments, I wonder if some of these questions are just posted to see how many idiots are among us.
illegal in canada
In every place I have hunted, that is illegal unless you are wheelchair bound. I agree with the above posts, it is not hunting, it is poaching. These people are bottom feeding, maggot munching, scum sucking, slime slurping lowlifes, not fit to be called a hunter, and I am not so sure they would qualify as human.
Big game hunting out of a vehicle is not legal in my area. Also, it is illegal to have a loaded gun or even a clip in your gun while in a vehicle. Nonetheless, those who hunted on remote roads back when there were no such laws will acknowledge their rifles were by their sides in the truck. In the 1950' and 60's, the oilfield guy did not feel wrong to do so on the way to his remote location. These were not gentlemen hunters with plenty of leisure time, they were working guys trying to fit some hunting time into demanding careers. They could legitimately claim to be hunting to feed the family. Times have changed and no one can justify this type of big game hunting today.
Just for a little perspective--One of our favorite outings as kids was in a relation's convertible with our bolt action single shot .22' s out each side, working our way across the gopher fields. Those ranchers invited us to come to shoot their gophers and we had a ball. Today, there would probably be a swat team waiting for us at the gate. So, in a relatively short space of time what would have been considered a harmless outing is now considered to be a criminal activity. That outing would feel as right to me today as it did over 40 years ago and rules be damned I would do it again with my grandkids given the opportunity.
Definitely illegal in Maine
It is illegal, unethical and reprehensible. Kody, you brought back memories for me of riding in a jeep on a ranch in Florida shooting armadillos (with permission and encouragement, of course). They say you can always identify a truck hunter because the barrel of his gun is rusty from riding around with it stuck out the window on rainy days.
To the individual who gigged my post, is it because you don't like me calling them poachers or because I identified them correctly as the low lifes they are? Too close to home, maybe?
Illegal in Wisconsin. You can't even lean a firearm against the vehicle.
A number of years ago I was injured in a car accident. My wife would take me out in her Toyota 4wheel drive station wagon,We would drive to a good hunting spot on a ridge, and use the car as a hunting blind.Now after years of recovery i'm back to hunting the old fashion way. thanks to 4wheel drives and good wives.
Bo, this whole topic & all the responses must have gotten under somebody's skin, but you really pissed in their cherios by calling them what they are.
To blkgnome, your experience is different from what most of us are talking about here. I often joke with a friend of mine, a disabled Vietnam Vet, that if he gets any worse, we'll have to put a rocking chair in the back of the truck for him to hunt out of. If he does get much worse, my freindly teasing might end up not far from reality.
It's poaching.
Definitely illegal in Pennsylvania and Montana.
Yes hunting from a vehicle window is illegal in pretty much every state, unless like in the case of my dad, your disabled. Disabled hunters cam get special hunting licenses which allow them to shoot from their windows of a vehicle. My father has a back condition that causes numbness in his legs after standing for only a few minutes, therefore he can't do alot of walking or standing. So before you condemn everyone who shoots from a window, see first if it's their only option.
It's one thing being a disabled hunter and shooting from a vehicle and another thing NOT being a disabled hunter shooting from a vehicle. I believe everybody posting are not bad mouthing disabled hunters; they are bad mouthing the abled and willing who have the mobility through their legs and being, but choose to be lazy, good for nothings (and what BO says goes double for me).
People who have nothing wrong with their bodies don't know how lucky they are to be mobile, to run, take a deep breathe, to jump,...... to be free.
pbrlover1081, if you read the comments, disability is excused. It is the low life maggots who aren't disabled but won't abide by standard sporting values and hunt fairly that irritate us. In most states there is a disability clause and those that are disabled are excused.
I don't know anyone on this site that would not excuse someone with a disability from hunting from a vehicle.
Didn't mean to get you in a lather. We were talking about the maggot-ridden life forms that want to cheat on the rules, not people with disabilities. I have a son who is completely disabled and I am fully aware of the complications a disability can add to one's life.
I'm getting up there 66yrs but here in Idaho no shooting from any vehicle so the same applies to the ATV'S. Come on Find them on the quad if you must but stalk em and shoot from your feet.
I would like to see quads and such ATV's banned from the Eastern slope of the Rockies. Many of the oil field roads that were pushed through sensitive areas along the rockies were closed for good reason. First of all they were ugly slashes in some of the most beautiful country in North America. Furthermore, they became a pipeline to prime habitat and a threat to the herds living in there. They also spawned terrible abuses by poachers. Now we have ATV's ripping up the landscape - apart use by disabled fellows it is not a question of if they will be banned it is a question of when they will be banned. They are tough on the environment and even tougher to justify in terms of fair chase. It is time to get back to the root of hunting using your own legs or those of a horse and shedding the big dollar toys.
Illegal in Arizona. Get caught doing that and you will have a hefty fine to pay and could get your gun and or your truck taken away. Also, your ability to hunt in the state ever again.
I had to read Tanner’s question a few times before I answered and it seems that Tanner just needs some education. Tanner your “friends” are NOT hunting. Hunting is getting out of a vehicle and allowing fair chase. Some times there are easy shots at game and other times you may get skunked. Sitting on your brain in a vehicle isn’t hunting that’s just stupid.
My father is 91 and uses a Honda Accord Hatchback as his atv on his 1700 acre farm and parks it in the woods...its equipped with a microwave and a tv..rolls the windows down and turns on his electric heater and does shoot his deer from a rolled down window...drives over honks the horn and we head over and listen to his story about the shot and clean his deer and load it in the hatchback for him to drive to the house..all on his property...never on or from a road...the car allows him to hunt in comfort on a farm of pine trees that are planted about 8 feet apart and the old honda fits between the trees and allows Dad to keep hunting in comfort.
Post an Answer (200 characters or less)
That's not hunting, that's illegal; illegal in my home state anyway...What about the rest of you? Is it illegal in your home state to hunt like tanner.leibel mentions? People like that give hunters a bad name and I would not label them hunters, but poachers. I wouldn't put it past those 'hunters' to go out at night with a spot light, a few beers, and continue their shooting out of a vehicle routine. Stick with your way of hunting tanner.leibel, you are doing it right.
I don't like it at all, even where it might be legal. In most places, that's poaching.
Definitely not hunting. If my friends did that they would very quickly become my ex-friends.
In every place I have hunted, that is illegal unless you are wheelchair bound. I agree with the above posts, it is not hunting, it is poaching. These people are bottom feeding, maggot munching, scum sucking, slime slurping lowlifes, not fit to be called a hunter, and I am not so sure they would qualify as human.
Bo, this whole topic & all the responses must have gotten under somebody's skin, but you really pissed in their cherios by calling them what they are.
To blkgnome, your experience is different from what most of us are talking about here. I often joke with a friend of mine, a disabled Vietnam Vet, that if he gets any worse, we'll have to put a rocking chair in the back of the truck for him to hunt out of. If he does get much worse, my freindly teasing might end up not far from reality.
It's one thing being a disabled hunter and shooting from a vehicle and another thing NOT being a disabled hunter shooting from a vehicle. I believe everybody posting are not bad mouthing disabled hunters; they are bad mouthing the abled and willing who have the mobility through their legs and being, but choose to be lazy, good for nothings (and what BO says goes double for me).
People who have nothing wrong with their bodies don't know how lucky they are to be mobile, to run, take a deep breathe, to jump,...... to be free.
pbrlover1081, if you read the comments, disability is excused. It is the low life maggots who aren't disabled but won't abide by standard sporting values and hunt fairly that irritate us. In most states there is a disability clause and those that are disabled are excused.
I don't know anyone on this site that would not excuse someone with a disability from hunting from a vehicle.
Didn't mean to get you in a lather. We were talking about the maggot-ridden life forms that want to cheat on the rules, not people with disabilities. I have a son who is completely disabled and I am fully aware of the complications a disability can add to one's life.
I'm getting up there 66yrs but here in Idaho no shooting from any vehicle so the same applies to the ATV'S. Come on Find them on the quad if you must but stalk em and shoot from your feet.
To the individual who gigged my post, is it because you don't like me calling them poachers or because I identified them correctly as the low lifes they are? Too close to home, maybe?
I would like to see quads and such ATV's banned from the Eastern slope of the Rockies. Many of the oil field roads that were pushed through sensitive areas along the rockies were closed for good reason. First of all they were ugly slashes in some of the most beautiful country in North America. Furthermore, they became a pipeline to prime habitat and a threat to the herds living in there. They also spawned terrible abuses by poachers. Now we have ATV's ripping up the landscape - apart use by disabled fellows it is not a question of if they will be banned it is a question of when they will be banned. They are tough on the environment and even tougher to justify in terms of fair chase. It is time to get back to the root of hunting using your own legs or those of a horse and shedding the big dollar toys.
My father is 91 and uses a Honda Accord Hatchback as his atv on his 1700 acre farm and parks it in the woods...its equipped with a microwave and a tv..rolls the windows down and turns on his electric heater and does shoot his deer from a rolled down window...drives over honks the horn and we head over and listen to his story about the shot and clean his deer and load it in the hatchback for him to drive to the house..all on his property...never on or from a road...the car allows him to hunt in comfort on a farm of pine trees that are planted about 8 feet apart and the old honda fits between the trees and allows Dad to keep hunting in comfort.
If they are parked on their own property, its not poaching. However I don't like it. My father in law likes to ride around on our places and hunt. He doesnt like to sit in a stand. I dont know if this is what the op was talking about but either way its not hunting.
Illegal in Mt.
In my more paranoid moments, I wonder if some of these questions are just posted to see how many idiots are among us.
illegal in canada
Big game hunting out of a vehicle is not legal in my area. Also, it is illegal to have a loaded gun or even a clip in your gun while in a vehicle. Nonetheless, those who hunted on remote roads back when there were no such laws will acknowledge their rifles were by their sides in the truck. In the 1950' and 60's, the oilfield guy did not feel wrong to do so on the way to his remote location. These were not gentlemen hunters with plenty of leisure time, they were working guys trying to fit some hunting time into demanding careers. They could legitimately claim to be hunting to feed the family. Times have changed and no one can justify this type of big game hunting today.
Just for a little perspective--One of our favorite outings as kids was in a relation's convertible with our bolt action single shot .22' s out each side, working our way across the gopher fields. Those ranchers invited us to come to shoot their gophers and we had a ball. Today, there would probably be a swat team waiting for us at the gate. So, in a relatively short space of time what would have been considered a harmless outing is now considered to be a criminal activity. That outing would feel as right to me today as it did over 40 years ago and rules be damned I would do it again with my grandkids given the opportunity.
Definitely illegal in Maine
It is illegal, unethical and reprehensible. Kody, you brought back memories for me of riding in a jeep on a ranch in Florida shooting armadillos (with permission and encouragement, of course). They say you can always identify a truck hunter because the barrel of his gun is rusty from riding around with it stuck out the window on rainy days.
Illegal in Wisconsin. You can't even lean a firearm against the vehicle.
A number of years ago I was injured in a car accident. My wife would take me out in her Toyota 4wheel drive station wagon,We would drive to a good hunting spot on a ridge, and use the car as a hunting blind.Now after years of recovery i'm back to hunting the old fashion way. thanks to 4wheel drives and good wives.
It's poaching.
Definitely illegal in Pennsylvania and Montana.
Yes hunting from a vehicle window is illegal in pretty much every state, unless like in the case of my dad, your disabled. Disabled hunters cam get special hunting licenses which allow them to shoot from their windows of a vehicle. My father has a back condition that causes numbness in his legs after standing for only a few minutes, therefore he can't do alot of walking or standing. So before you condemn everyone who shoots from a window, see first if it's their only option.
Illegal in Arizona. Get caught doing that and you will have a hefty fine to pay and could get your gun and or your truck taken away. Also, your ability to hunt in the state ever again.
I had to read Tanner’s question a few times before I answered and it seems that Tanner just needs some education. Tanner your “friends” are NOT hunting. Hunting is getting out of a vehicle and allowing fair chase. Some times there are easy shots at game and other times you may get skunked. Sitting on your brain in a vehicle isn’t hunting that’s just stupid.
Post an Answer (200 characters or less)