October 18, 2011
Whitetail Tips: Ambush Mature Bucks With a Setback Stand - 1
Neil Dougherty, a whitetail property consultant, can walk a deer woods anywhere in the country and point out stand locations before they even come into view. He's able to do this because most deer hunters are predictable. We hunt the same funnels, saddles and field corners year after year.
The problem is that if Dougherty can pick off stand sites on a new property, so can a mature whitetail that has lived on the same stretch of land his whole life. A smart old buck will find a hunter's stand and then walk around it staying just far enough away to go undetected. Because of this, one of Dougherty's deadliest tactics is the setback stand.
How it Works
In the beginning of the season, hunt your primary stand. Hunting the primary stand will train the deer to travel down wind of that spot to smell the hunter in the tree. As the season progresses and the mature deer start to move during daylight hours, go to your setback stand. By the end of the season, you should be hunting your second setback stand (your third stand back). This sounds like an easy concept, but it can get frustrating hunting a setback stand. Typically, the further down wind of the primary stand you hunt, the lower the deer sightings. This is especially true if the primary stand is located over a primary food source. However, Dougherty and his clients have reported that they see more mature deer out of the set back stands than the primary stands.
"It becomes a test of wills … can you sit there long enough [to wait out a mature buck?]" Dougherty says.
When the time is right, he'll give his setback stands one or two all-day sits. If he doesn't get a chance at a big buck, he'll switch locations and try a different area of his hunting property. But if you play the wind right, and the big guy is in the block of woods your hunting, there's a good chance you're going to get a crack at him on the first day you hunt the setback stand, Dougherty says.
Why It Works
For the setback stand strategy to work, you have to be willing to accept the fact that a mature whitetail buck can pattern you as a hunter, Dougherty says. Given enough time, he can locate your stand location, figure out how you get into the woods and how you get out and then move around you.
Once you are able to make that mental leap of faith, setting up in thick cover void of any deer sign won't seem like such a crazy idea.
Editor's Note: Each year wildlife consultant Neil Dougherty kills more than 100 mature whitetail bucks. But rarely pulls the trigger. His clients do the trigger pulling on the hundreds of properties he helps them manage. His unique approaches to property layout and hunting techniques have been featured on TV, and written about extensively. He prefers to hunt whitetails on his home property in western NY where he manages to take more than his share of mature bucks but still measures his success by the success of his clients.