Please Sign In

Please enter a valid username and password
  • Log in with Facebook
» Not a member? Take a moment to register
» Forgot Username or Password

Battle Over Riverbed Ownership Continues in North Carolina

August 06, 2013
Battle Over Riverbed Ownership Continues in North Carolina - 0

The state of North Carolina will challenge Alcoa Inc.'s assertion that it owns a 38-mile stretch of riverbed in the Yadkin River, filing a lawsuit on August 2 that could have broad implications for public access to water bodies nationwide.
State officials claim Alcoa has no ownership rights to the bed of the Yadkin River, over which four dams were built beginning a century ago. The lawsuit asks a Wake County judge to rule that the state retains ownership rights to the submerged land, so North Carolina will have a financial stake in power produced by the hydropower dams.
The state and a grassroots coalition of local groups, spearheaded by the Yadkin Riverkeeper Inc., are also contesting Alcoa's effort to secure a new federal license -- 401 Certification Application -- that would allow it to continue operating the dams for up to 50 years.
The river runs for about 200 miles to the east of Charlotte and becomes the Pee Dee River before entering South Carolina en route to the Atlantic. The dams powered an aluminum smelter that closed in 2007 and Alcoa has since sold the electricity to commercial customers.
But North Carolina says that water isn't Alcoa's to sell.
"The Yadkin River is a North Carolina river," Gov. Pat McCrory told the Associated Press. "We should be able to use it for North Carolina water needs and to create North Carolina jobs. The benefits of the Yadkin River belong to North Carolina’s people."
Pittsburgh-based Alcoa said it will ask the case be moved to federal court.
"We believe this filing is flat-out wrong. Ownership of submerged lands is a question of federal law -- and we will immediately begin the legal process to move it to federal court," Alcoa's E. Ray Barham told the AP. Alcoa "is confident in its ownership position and that it will be firmly established in court."
The company noted that the U.S. Supreme Court last year issued a ruling on riverbed property rights in PPL Montana vs. the State of Montana that would favor its stance.
The Supreme Court sided in 2012 with PPL Montana over who owns the riverbeds beneath 10 dams on three rivers. Montana sought to collect more than $50 million in back rent and interest after that state’s highest court determined the state owns the submerged land beneath the dams. The Supreme Court ruled that navigability must be determined on a section by section basis, not on rivers in their entirety.
Yadkin Riverkeeper Inc. has been disputing Alcoa’s ownership claims for years, always maintaining that public waters cannot be sold away for private gain.
"No FERC license and no settlement agreement should give that exclusive right to a single corporation or a private interest," it says in a position statement.
In 2009, Yadkin Riverkeeper supported North Carolina’s request to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to give back the Yadkin to the state.
"The state has a legal obligation to find out who owns this important resource," Yadkin Riverkeeper Dean Naujoks said. "Alcoa had numerous opportunities to provide the proper deeds of ownership and put this whole issue to rest more than a year ago."
There's another reason to wrestle ownership from Alcoa, Naujoks says:
"The Yadkin River is still not fishable as result of Alcoa’s extensive pollution problems," he said. "The company is still failing to comply with dissolved oxygen standards and cannot demonstrate title of ownership. Our members remain concerned that (401 relicensing) will be used as a shield to preserve the status quo from enforcement efforts for years to come."

For more, go to
-- NC challenges Alcoa’s property rights for dams
-- Take Action Now to Stop Alcoa's 50 Year Takeover
-- Alcoa and the Yadkin River: What’s next?
-- Who owns the Yadkin River - revisited
-- No clarity on who owns the Yadkin riverbed
-- Yadkin River Navigability and Riverbed Ownership
-- Alcoa and the great North Carolina power grab


Post a Comment (200 characters or less)

Post a Comment (200 characters or less)


About Open Country

Hunters and anglers across the nation consistently list one challenge as their primary obstacle to spending more time in the field: Access.

Outdoor Life's Open Country program aims to tackle that issue head on and with boots on the ground. The program highlights volunteer-driven efforts to improve access along with habitat improvements to make existing public lands even better places to hunt and fish. The program's goal is to substantially increase sportsman's access across the country by promoting events that make a difference.

Here on Open Country's blog page, contributors take a close look at access issues across the country. Some are public-policy discussions, where we investigate the nuances of public access. In other blogs, we shine a light on attempts to turn public recreation opportunities into private hunting and fishing domains. In still other blogs, we interview decision makers about access issues. Together, we fight for the ability of America's hunters and anglers to have a place to swing a gun or wet a line.

We promise the discussion is always lively, interesting, and fresh, so visit this page frequently to tune into the latest access issue.

The Open Country program culminates in grants and awards with top projects and participants being honored.

Submit a project for the Open Country Grant Award.
Nominate an individual for the Open Country Award.

Open Country



Event Calendar

  • June 1: Red Oak Planting in Gwinn Forest Management Unit
  • June 7: Pinegrass Restoration, Willamette River (Eugene, OR REMF Chapter). Contact.
  • June 7-8: Lower Deschutes River Thistle Cut (OR Foundation for North American Wild Sheep and OR Fish and Wildlife). Contact.
  • June 13-15: Prairie City Aspen Habitat Enhancement (Oregon Hunters Association, Capitol Chapter) Contact: 503-399-1234
  • June 21: Smith Ridge Meadows (Eugene, OR Chapter RMEF). Contact.