|
|
|
Welcome to Outdoor Life
Big Game
I recently came across a story about a buffalo that somehow wound up in a residential neighborhood in Michigan. After authorities made an attempt to divert the animal (fat chance with a full-grown buffalo, guys!), they had to shoot and kill the thing.
Of course, when something like that happens (whether it's with a deer that walks into a town, a bear too close to a school, etc) there seems to be a large outcry from angry people saying, "Why couldn't the authorities tranquilized the animal!?"
I'm not about the jump on the bandwagon because I think it's simply hard to plan accordingly for a situation where the wild animals come into human spots...BUT, it's a legitimate question. Why don't they ever tranquilize? Think about it--you very rarely read about police/authorities tranquilizing these wandering animals; they are usually "forced" to kill them. It's a shame, because the animals could presumably be released back into the wild and, if killed by a human at some point, at least it would have been done under the principle of fair chase.
Do most police not stock tranquilizers in their arsenal? Is it too difficult to successfully tranquilize an animal (ie, are there too many things that could go wrong)?
I'm very curious to hear some thoughts from people--and especially if anyone knows any specifics about tranquilizing big-game.
Considering Buffalo are raised like cattle in the midwest, it would probably be easier to have it killed rather than careful transport to the place where it was originally being farmed to be killed later for meat?
Just a thought.
Speaking from a health care professional standpoint, there are a whole lot of reasons why this is such a sticky problem. Most medication like tranquilizer for animals are dosage calculated by weight. You give too much you kill the animal, too little there is insufficient response and a would be rescuer gets hurt. There are also some of those meds are species specific, what will work for one may kill another or have no effect. Outside of needing to an accurate weight on an animal and then having a variety of different kinds of meds, well, you can see it is way too expensive to keep a vet on call for those kinds of issues. Sad to say, there is a time when the only way that is reasonably affordable for most places that have that problem is to take the animal down. A bullet doesn't cost much, some of the meds do cost a lot.
True alot of the time cost is a factor in the choice. It also costs less to transport a carcass than it does to transport live animals. A friend of mine working with cattle had a truck hauling cattle tip and they had cattle running around, it was just easier and more cost effective to shoot them than have to put them to sleep and carefully package them back into another truck. Also to note is that in many cases tranquilizers had been used and the animal is just a problem animal that returns multiple times.
I have worked buffalo a couple of times for different people and you don't herd them anywhere. You sort of suggest for them to go a certain way and if they don't you get the hell out of the way. That being said I think alot would depend on the danger to the immediate population. As stated above tranquilizing one is tricky because of the weight issue. How would you like to go out with the trash and see that standing in your yard. LOL
all good comments sounds to me like lead is the best tranquiler,
6p, Not just lead, but large bore, jacketed lead. ;)
What do you have to do to get tranquilizers? How much do they actually cost? I would like to have a tranquilizer to shoot rabbits and put them in my running pen, any thoughts
Post a Reply (200 characters or less)
Considering Buffalo are raised like cattle in the midwest, it would probably be easier to have it killed rather than careful transport to the place where it was originally being farmed to be killed later for meat?
Just a thought.
Speaking from a health care professional standpoint, there are a whole lot of reasons why this is such a sticky problem. Most medication like tranquilizer for animals are dosage calculated by weight. You give too much you kill the animal, too little there is insufficient response and a would be rescuer gets hurt. There are also some of those meds are species specific, what will work for one may kill another or have no effect. Outside of needing to an accurate weight on an animal and then having a variety of different kinds of meds, well, you can see it is way too expensive to keep a vet on call for those kinds of issues. Sad to say, there is a time when the only way that is reasonably affordable for most places that have that problem is to take the animal down. A bullet doesn't cost much, some of the meds do cost a lot.
True alot of the time cost is a factor in the choice. It also costs less to transport a carcass than it does to transport live animals. A friend of mine working with cattle had a truck hauling cattle tip and they had cattle running around, it was just easier and more cost effective to shoot them than have to put them to sleep and carefully package them back into another truck. Also to note is that in many cases tranquilizers had been used and the animal is just a problem animal that returns multiple times.
I have worked buffalo a couple of times for different people and you don't herd them anywhere. You sort of suggest for them to go a certain way and if they don't you get the hell out of the way. That being said I think alot would depend on the danger to the immediate population. As stated above tranquilizing one is tricky because of the weight issue. How would you like to go out with the trash and see that standing in your yard. LOL
all good comments sounds to me like lead is the best tranquiler,
6p, Not just lead, but large bore, jacketed lead. ;)
What do you have to do to get tranquilizers? How much do they actually cost? I would like to have a tranquilizer to shoot rabbits and put them in my running pen, any thoughts
Post a Reply (200 characters or less)