25 Top Deer Questions

Question: So today my mom grounded me because apparently I'm too obsessed with hunting and need to focus on other things like school work. The funny thing is my lowest grade in school is an 89. She thinks all I worry about is hunting. Even though I love hunting, I do have a life beside it but apparently I'm not supposed to do what I love. Your thoughts??
-erict8** Answer:** Future tip: Pick your college classes carefully so you can maximize your hunting and fishing time, and do all the homework beforehand if you can so you don't have to cut class once or twice a week to hunt mornings.
--Yoda****
Question: If you don't remove the windpipe when field dressing a deer will it spoil your meat?
--wewek Answer: No it won't spoil the meat. I reach up as far as I can and cut it off.
--Johnnie
Question: I was in my stand today and saw what looked like a doe at distance and then I heard and saw her snort, can they do that or was it a button buck?
--Evan.hensel Answer: Yes as a warning ... usually a warning to the fawn and stamping their front hoof on the ground can also be signal that all is not well.
--the decoy hunter Photo: Emery_Way
Question: I'm hunting a 40-acre plot of land in New Jersey. There are blue berries in the middle of the plot and corn on the edges. If you were a deer, which one would you be in the most? I have set up along the corn for the past week and have seen nothing moving. Any ideas?
--pjsabella Answer: Focus on the corn. Since you are not seeing deer along the edges, the deer are deep in the field. On a windy day, stalk across rows into the corn looking for bedded or standing deer in each row as you move. I have killed many deer doing this. Modern deer expect danger from trees along field edges they don't expect danger while lounging deep in the corn.
--Charlie Elk
Question: Just a curious question for all you bowhunters: What's your farthest kill shot with a bow?
--jhuff2010 Answer: 58 yards, I was young and dumb. Nothing over 30 yards these days.
-- Ishi Photo: Mr. Barndoor
Question: I have seen different studies on "home range" of whitetail deer. I hunt in southern Wisconsin where is it huge crop field, one after another. When the crops are up, the land could support many deer and keep them in a relatively small area. After the crops are picked, there are very few places for the deer to hide. How is the home range affected after all the crops are gone? Will the deer come back when the fields are plentiful the following year? Answer: A big bruiser not hot on a doe can hide in some of the smallest places. Cover you wouldn't think would hold a pheasant just might provide enough security for a deer, especially if they can see danger coming in all directions.
--Sangcoacc
Question: How much of your deer meat do you donate to others?
--6phunter Answer: I donate 75 percent of the meat I take down. I donate to my elders, family who can't hunt, single parents, ect. It's a traditional thing for local hunters to feed those who like the meat and can't get it for themselves. There is no shame in asking a hunter for meat, it's more of a honor for the hunter, plus it clears the freezer so we can get more hunting in.
--dropjhook.com
Question: My (city) cousin asked me, "what is so addictive to so many hunters about waking up early, freezing your butt off, and waiting alone in the woods just for an opportunity to shoot a deer?"...
--evan.hensel Answer: Ask her what's so great about waking up to car horns, breathing exhaust fumes and walking on crowded sidewalks while you still get to freeze your butt off and wonder if a mugger is going to shoot you.
--Seadog
Question: Can smoke and light from a fire scare deer away or make them nervous?
--MNwhitetailHunter Answer: In cold weather I've warmed my hands over a small kindling fire and taken deer. Deer are individuals. Some will undoubtedly spook, some might be curious, others may simply disregard it.
--6phunter
Question: What is an easy way to scout deer and turkeys when you don't have a lot of time?
--Nolan Answer: Pick a good looking spot and set up. Observe your surroundings and activity while you hunt and make decisions to move your setup based on what you know and what you have learned. I shot a decent 8-pointer this fall using this strategy over a period of about three days. By the moment of truth, it was almost as if I had drawn it up in a playbook.
--Sangcoacc
Question: What time of year is best to plant a food plot spring or fall? Which is best annuals or perennials?
--Cornbuck Answer: You can plant both -- do a soil test perhaps at your local farm store or garden center before you buy seed to establish what will perform best on your site. Alfalfa, clover, trefoil are all forage plants that will provide food year after year.
--the decoy hunter
Question: With most of the hunting seasons coming during cold weather, hunters go to the extreme to stay warm. What does a deer do to guarantee it's survival during the cold weather?
--LDurbin Answer: During cold weather, whitetails are much more active, feeding and moving around during times when they may normally bed. They require extra calories to maintain body heat. They may also move to areas of the thickest cover, to help block heat-stealing winds.
--Bigjake
Question: What's the best deer rifle for the money, new or used.
--cwp72 Answer: The best deer rifle is dependent on where you are hunting. If you are hunting in the West where you may be making a long shot, you may find that you need a different gun than you would in, say the wooded areas of Pennsylvania, Kentucky, Tennessee or Arkansas. What works in Wyoming, Colorado, Kansas, Nebraska or Western Oklahoma where shots can be several hundred yards will not work in an area where you may never be able to see anything further than 60 yards. Where are you going to be hunting? Then we can talk about the best gun for your situation. There is no one size fits all when it comes to deer hunting situations in the US. The terrain dictates that you adapt to it, not the other way around.
--BO
Question: While doing some early scouting I noticed two trails, an often-used trail with small hoof marks (does) and a much less-used trail with much larger hoof marks (buck). Where do I set up my stand to tag a shooter during rut?
--Evan.hensel Answer: The inertia of the rut will translate into much different patterns and practices -- however you have identified some late spring travel routes and deer populations. This may change as late summer/early autumn food sources become available. The best plan is to continue to monitor deer activity and see how it evolves through the summer and into the pre-rut stage. You will be able to make a better choice at this time.
--the decoy hunter Photo: Noel Zia Lee
Question: If a deer notices me in my tree stand and doesn't really spook, but just notices that something isn't right and moves off. How long will it remember that encounter? Have I blown my stand placement, or will that deer eventually forget what happened?
--bowhunterjac Answer: Scare a deer once and expect it to be gone a day or two. Scare a deer twice and it may be gone for a week. After a third time, a deer may change it's pattern completely to avoid your location altogether.
--Ishi
Question: does anyone have any ideas of cool mounts for deer a hoof? My father made his into a coat rack. I'm trying to get something different.
--abfreddie64 Answer: How about a handle for a knife that you make?
There are "kits" that can help you with this.
-- Big O Photo: Charles and Clint
Question: Why don't some people hunt?
--Preston Answer: Video games, no sense of adventure and nobody to introduce them to the sport …
--MWK_MN
Question: I have been watching this huge buck for two or three years now and just can't seem to get on top of him. He has two main trails and I have set up on each, but he will alway go on the opposite one I'm on. I have done every thing from decoys to scents to baits. I was wondering if you guys have any tips or advice to help me get this monster.
--duck101 Answer: If you are just concentrating on the two main trails, try and mix it up by setting up either beyond or before your old sites. Look for natural funnels of timber or overgrown transition areas that are narrow and act as staging areas for travel between points A and B. So take a second look at your hunting area and see if you can visualize any of these natural "highways" that exist and then look for potential sites for a ground blind or tree stand.
-- the decoy hunter
Question: I have noticed many hunter's comments on this site talking about how small the bucks' racks are in the Northeast. What are the main reason's for this? Poor quality deer management, genetics, nutrition, etc? Just curious, thanks.
--MWK_MN Answer: I have seen huge deer come from the most unlikely places. I don't think any one factor controls the size of the antlers. But all deer are not equal. Our swamp deer here in Alabama are small genetically by design, but 50 miles north in the pine hills there are big deer. Darwin is at work here.
--jacy1515 Photo: Daniel Case

We've put together the best, strangest and funniest deer hunting questions asked by OL readers. But don't worry, we've also included the best answers to each question.