Ice Fishing: How to Catch Monster Late-Winter Pike

As ice-out approaches, big pike begin their migration from deepwater wintertime haunts to shallow spawning bays, providing anglers with their best opportunity to catch a true giant.

Photo by Steve Pennaz

When you are standing on an ice sheet that’s 36 inches thick, it seems absurd to think that spring is in the air. But it was. And I could feel it.

It was the last week of March, and Pete Palony and I had planned our trip to Minnesota’s famed Lake of the Woods to be here at this precise time. This sprawling inland sea is home to massive numbers of huge pike.

The first flag went off a half hour into the day. A pike attacked a live sucker pinned 6 feet off the bottom in 14 feet of water. Within minutes, 14 pounds of thrashing fish hit the ice. We released it after a couple of quick photos.

Then one of the cisco-baited tip-ups went off. I set the hook, and it felt as if I was tethered to a moving truck. The fish exploded in an impressive run; for a few seconds I worried that my 50 yards of main line might not be stout enough.

The pike made three long runs before I could coax its massive head through the 10-inch hole. When the tip of its nose appeared out of the slush, I reached in to grab a gill plate.

You have to stand up to lift 44 inches of pike from a hole in the ice.

Pike Perceptions

Although one look at a pike’s toothy maw confirms that it evolved to feed on other fish, here’s what you may not know about northerns: They are scavengers that feed on dead stuff, too. And in late winter, there are plenty of dead things in the shallow back bays of lakes that see oxygen levels plummet over the long winter.

Embracing this part of pike behavior was difficult for me. As I learned to target big pike, however, I started to understand the significant differences between hammer-handle fish and studs.

The use of underwater cameras like the Aqua-Vu Micro AV has accelerated my learning. For example, I’ve discovered that big pike are attracted to vertically jigged rattle baits and will travel hundreds of feet to investigate them. Flutter spoons are similarly enticing. These thin spoons are very popular with the Great Lakes trollers that target trout and salmon. Unlike traditional spoons, these light baits sink slowly on the drop, attracting pike as they flutter down. Rig these lures in tandem with live or dead baits.

Both dead and live baits produce below tip-ups. A quick-strike rig will not only allow you to safely release fish, but it will also greatly improve your strike-to-hookup rate. I use 40-pound fluorocarbon for my leader, with about 30 inches between my main line and the bait. Smaller trebles—I use No. 4 almost exclusively—offer better landing rates than larger ones. Thin, uncoated seven-strand wire is also a popular leader material for preventing bite-offs by toothy pike. Most anglers I know use 18- to 27-pound-test to build their rigs.

I like a thick, strong main line for giant pike. You don’t need 50-pound-test to land them, but heavier lines are easiest to handle with cold, wet hands. Berkley’s Gorilla Braid is made with both Dyneema and Dacron, and it offers the best characteristics of both. It not only sinks, but it’s also easy to control and can withstand the sharp edges that form around ice holes.

Pike Pointers

▶ Late-season pike roam much higher in the water column than most anglers realize. Often, my best baits are those pinned just a foot or two below the ice.

▶ Follow the bait to find big late-season fish. In waters with a strong panfish forage base, seek out the shallow bays that attract them and you’ll find pike.

▶ In waters dominated by open-water forage such as whitefish, shallower rocky points can be great pike spots, particularly near spawning areas.

▶ Because current attracts and concentrates fish, incoming creeks and rivers are a plus.

▶ If you are not finding fish shallow, focus on pike staging areas, like deep water close to spawning bays.

▶ Once you hook a giant, allow it to run. The last thing you want is a green fish at the bottom of the hole, where it could bury your hooks into the ice.