The pair approached the buck in disbelief. Makayla and her father disagreed about the buck's identity. Hay insisted the deer was the same buck from the river, but Makayla didn't think so. Referencing the photo proved Hay was correct. "I'm over here just trying to count points and he's like, 'You shot my deer,'" Makayla said. "I had to count several times because I just couldn't believe it."